St. Paul's Methodist Church is a small Methodist church building built on Orchard Street, Oyster Bay, New York in 1858 and now occupied by the North Shore Community Church. In 1895, Joseph B. Wright bought the building from them and continued his business there for many years. The congregation then moved to this building which they had been working on since 1891. By 1913 the congregation had expanded. To create more room the building was raised, a basement excavated, and several rooms including a kitchen were built. A forty foot bell tower was struck by lightning in the 1920s and had to be removed.